Coin Collector’s Dream: 7 More $1,200+ Rare Gems

5 Min Read

For enthusiasts of coin collecting, the excitement of stumbling upon a rare treasure is unmatched.

The realm of numismatics boasts an array of such prized possessions, some commanding prices upwards of $1,200 owing to their scarcity, historical importance, and condition.

This article explores seven more of these coveted coins, each a dream acquisition for serious collectors.

1849 Coronet Head Gold Double Eagle

The 1849 Coronet Head Gold Double Eagle holds a special position in numismatic lore.

Struck during the California Gold Rush, it was among the initial $20 gold pieces minted by the United States Mint. Its rarity is accentuated by its limited production; only a handful of specimens exist today.

Collectors prize this coin not only for its scarcity but also for its historical significance, symbolizing a crucial juncture in U.S. monetary history.

In pristine condition, its value can easily exceed $1,200, with prices reaching into the millions for the finest examples.

1916-D Mercury Dime

The 1916-D Mercury Dime is a pinnacle rarity in the Mercury Dime series. With a mintage of just over 264,000, it stands as the lowest among all Mercury Dimes.

This coin is highly coveted by collectors, especially in superior grades where it becomes exceptionally scarce.

The allure of the 1916-D lies in its blend of age, elegance, and rarity.

In uncirculated condition, this dime can command well over $1,200, with top-tier specimens fetching significantly higher prices.

1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel

This distinctive variant of the Buffalo Nickel arose from a minting error, resulting in the inadvertent removal of the buffalo’s front leg from the die.

The 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel is a favorite among collectors for its peculiarity and the narrative surrounding its creation.

Despite its initial large mintage, the number of 3-legged varieties is considerably lower, rendering it a scarce find.

In decent condition, this coin easily surpasses the $1,200 mark, particularly if it retains sharp details and minimal wear.

1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar

The 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar holds the distinction of being one of the earliest silver dollars minted by the United States.

Its historical significance, coupled with its age and scarcity, renders it a highly coveted item.

With only a limited quantity minted and even fewer surviving in good condition, this coin is a numismatic legend.

Well-maintained examples can command astronomical prices, far exceeding the $1,200 threshold.

1893-S Morgan Silver Dollar

Dubbed the monarch of Morgan Dollars, the 1893-S boasts the lowest mintage of the entire series, with only 100,000 coins struck.

Its rarity is compounded by extensive circulation, leaving few in high grades.

For enthusiasts of Morgan Dollars, the 1893-S is a coveted prize, and its value reflects its esteemed status.

Even in lower grades, this coin can fetch prices well over $1,200, with mint-condition specimens being particularly valuable.

1955 Double Die Lincoln Cent

The 1955 Double Die Lincoln Cent stands as one of the most renowned error coins in American numismatics.

As a result of misalignment during the minting process, these cents display noticeably doubled inscriptions and dates.

While the total mintage remains uncertain, their rarity is evident. Collectors cherish this coin for its error and the clarity of the doubling.

In superior grades, it can easily surpass the $1,200 mark, with flawless examples commanding significantly higher prices.

2000-P Sacagawea Dollar “Cheerios”

The 2000-P Sacagawea Dollar, famously known as the “Cheerios” dollar, is a contemporary rarity.

These coins, distributed in Cheerios cereal boxes as part of a promotion, feature a distinctive tail feather detail distinct from regular issues.

Only 5,500 were distributed in this manner, rendering them a scarce find. In pristine condition, these coins can fetch well over $1,200, appealing to both contemporary coin collectors and those intrigued by unique promotional items.


In summary, the realm of coin collecting abounds with rare and valuable specimens, each possessing its own tale and allure.

From historical treasures like the 1794 Flowing Hair Silver Dollar to modern anomalies such as the “Cheerios” Sacagawea Dollar, these coins represent more than mere monetary worth; they embody pieces of history, art, and culture.

For collectors, the pursuit of these rare treasures transcends mere hobbyism; it is a passion fueled by the thrill of discovery and a deep appreciation for their intrinsic and historical significance.

Share This Article
Leave a comment